投稿人
Tony Davidow, CIMA®
Senior Alternatives Investment Strategist
Franklin Templeton Institute
In a traditional private equity fund, a pension plan, endowment, foundation or family office (a privately held company that handles investment and wealth management for a wealthy family) commits to invest capital over a period of time (seven-10 years). They are considered limited partners in the fund (LPs). When the fund manager, also known as the general partner (GP), finds an attractive investment, they call for capital from the LPs’ (capital calls) original commitment.
The LPs understand that these are long-term investments, but sometimes they have liquidity needs, and they may seek a buyer for their ownership stake. These are referred to as secondaries transactions since the original owner seeks a secondary buyer.
Secondaries Pricing as a Percentage of Net Asset Value (All Strategies)
Source: Greenhill, 2022.
Notes: The secondary strategies include buyout, venture/growth, infrastructure, real estate and fund-of-funds/secondary funds. Past performances do not guarantee future returns.
As the data above illustrates, secondaries have traded at a discount to net asset value (NAV) since 2007, with more attractive pricing during periods of economic slowdowns. This is partially driven by the “denominator effect,” as public pension funds find themselves overallocated to alternative investments due to the decline in value of their public market positions. As institutional investors reduce or diversify their private equity, new investors have the ability to benefit through participating in secondaries and purchasing these positions at discounts.
According to PitchBook,1 secondaries fundraising rose from US$20 billion in 2006, to US$100 billion in 2020. Up until 2022, most funds could exit their investments through acquisitions or initial public offerings (IPOs). This created a lot of cash flow and liquidity for LPs. In 2022, exits began to slow dramatically, and have essentially dried-up since the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank. LPs will likely need some liquidity in the coming years to meet capital calls and diversify their holdings.
Global: Secondaries Fundraising Activity
Source: Pitchbook, as of March 31, 2023. Important data provider notices and terms available at www.franklintempletondatasources.com.
Secondaries managers can diversify their holdings based on the stages, geography, industry and vintage of the primary funds available. By diversifying vintage years, the secondaries manager can attempt to mitigate the J-Curve effect, where capital is drawn down as opportunities are sourced and returns are typically negative. Secondaries managers with experience and capital to deploy may be able to take advantage of the current market and find many attractive opportunities in the coming years.
In today’s market environment, with exits slowing dramatically from peak levels, we anticipate that many institutions and family offices will seek liquidity in the near future. We believe this scenario provides a significant opportunity for secondaries managers to select highly prized assets from a diverse pool and negotiate favorable pricing.
Endnote
- Source: PitchBook, “The Evolution of Private Market Secondaries,” April 20, 2023.
WHAT ARE THE RISKS?
All investments involve risks, including the possible loss of principal. The value of investments can go down as well as up, and investors may not get back the full amount invested. Stock prices fluctuate, sometimes rapidly and dramatically, due to factors affecting individual companies, particular industries or sectors, or general market conditions. Bond prices generally move in the opposite direction of interest rates. Thus, as prices of bonds in an investment portfolio adjust to a rise in interest rates, the value of the portfolio may decline.
Investing in private companies involves a number of significant risks, including that they: may have limited financial resources and may be unable to meet their obligations under their debt securities, which may be accompanied by a deterioration in the value of any collateral and a reduction in the likelihood of realizing any guarantees that may have obtained in connection with the investment; have shorter operating histories, narrower product lines and smaller market shares than larger businesses, which tend to render them more vulnerable to competitors’ actions and changing market conditions, as well as general economic downturns; are more likely to depend on the management talents and efforts of a small group of persons; therefore, the death, disability, resignation or termination of one or more of these persons could have a material adverse impact on the portfolio company and, in turn, on the investment; generally have less predictable operating results, may from time to time be parties to litigation, may be engaged in rapidly changing businesses with products subject to a substantial risk of obsolescence, and may require substantial additional capital to support their operations, finance expansion or maintain their competitive position.